Donald Clarke: Jimmy Kimmel was very polite about his recent Irish trip. But he is mistaken

Jimmy Kimmel’s Irish Visit and Politeness Compared

TV host Jimmy Kimmel recently shared his experience during a trip to Ireland, speaking highly of the country’s decency, friendliness, and political maturity. However, the assertion that Irish people are exceptionally polite and generous compared to others may be overstated.

A Personal Anecdote from New York

About 4,000 years ago, I visited New York City on a J1 visa. Early on, I tried to find a job related to my field, which required speaking with the union representing the workforce. The woman I met was incredibly helpful, as if I were a long-lost relative. She expressed surprise that I arrived without a job, then spent half an hour giving advice, job leads, and useful contacts. She concluded warmly,

“Now, don’t let anyone tell you New Yorkers are rude.”

Until then, I had only found New Yorkers occasionally brusque, but no less polite than those in other large cities. Few had time for lengthy chit-chat like people from rural areas.

Reflection on Kimmel’s Comments

This memory came to mind while watching Jimmy Kimmel discuss Ireland. Despite early jokes about leprechauns, his trip was mostly praise for Irish qualities. Still, Irish politeness and generosity are not unique compared to the kindness shown by people elsewhere, including New Yorkers.

Summary

While Kimmel’s admiration of Ireland is genuine, politeness and generosity are universal traits found in many societies, not uniquely Irish.

more

The Irish Times The Irish Times — 2025-11-02

More News