Josh Hutcherson's Controversial New HBO Show Sparks Fierce Critic & Audience Divide

Josh Hutcherson's Controversial New HBO Show Sparks Critic and Audience Divide

The HBO comedy series I Love LA premiered on November 2 and quickly generated mixed reactions from critics and audiences alike. Created by Rachel Sennott, the show follows a group of friends reuniting after years apart, exploring how their lives and relationships have evolved.

Critics' Perspective

Critics have largely praised the series, calling it a fresh take on absurdist comedy that resonates with Gen Z sensibilities. I Love LA currently holds an 81% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 32 critic reviews, earning it a Certified Fresh status.

Sam Adams for Slate noted that the show's “writing gets sharper” as it progresses.
Chris Vognar of the Boston Globe commended how the series makes its initially unlikable protagonists feel sympathetic.

Audience Reactions

In contrast, audience reception has been significantly more divided. The series holds a 59% audience score from fewer than 50 ratings on Rotten Tomatoes. While some viewers praise the humor and relatability for younger audiences, others criticize its stereotypical portrayal of Los Angeles and uneven emotional tone.

Summary

Despite the polarized reactions, I Love LA continues to spark discussion for its bold tone and generational humor, marking a noteworthy start for Josh Hutcherson’s latest HBO project.

Author’s summary: A divisive yet buzzworthy HBO premiere, I Love LA splits critics and viewers over its Gen Z humor, writing style, and portrayal of Los Angeles life.

more

Screen Rant Screen Rant — 2025-11-07

More News