The cowardly publishing world betrayed Kate Clanchy

The Cowardly Publishing World Betrayed Kate Clanchy

Has there finally been a shift in the publishing world? There might be emerging hope that this industry, once dominated by woke critics and strict cultural gatekeepers, is moving away from cancel culture and identity politics towards a more open and reasonable environment.

This apology offers little solace to Kate Clanchy, whose experience with cancel culture was especially harsh and undeserved.

Kate Clanchy's Cancellation

Kate Clanchy, a celebrated author, faced severe backlash in 2021 during the post-BLM turmoil. Her memoir, Some Kids I Taught and What They Taught Me, recounting her teaching years in an Oxford comprehensive, was labeled racist. Under pressure, her publisher distanced itself from her, leading to her departure from Picador after two decades in 2022.

Publisher's Formal Apology

Following a BBC Radio 4 investigation into Clanchy's public disgrace, Pan Macmillan—parent company of Picador—issued a formal apology. The company described the situation as a “regrettable series of events in Pan Macmillan’s past.”

“I’m sorry for the hurt that was caused to Kate Clanchy,” said Pan Macmillan CEO Joanna Prior.

Although the apology came late, it acknowledges the injustice Clanchy faced, which was both severe and unmerited.

Summary

Kate Clanchy’s unfair cancellation highlights the damaging effects of cancel culture, but recent industry shifts suggest a move towards more balanced cultural dialogue.

Would you like the tone to be more formal or conversational?

The Spectator Australia — 2025-11-06