‘All Her Fault’ Review: Sarah Snook, Dakota Fanning and Jake Lacy Anchor Peacock’s Satisfying Domestic Mystery

Michael Peña joins the cast of this eight-part thriller that revolves around the vanishing of a young boy from an affluent Chicago neighborhood. The story opens with a desperate mother’s plea as Marissa Irvine, portrayed by Sarah Snook, declares:

“We’d do anything for our kids. Anything.”

For Marissa, this is no exaggeration. When her five-year-old son Milo (Duke McCloud) goes missing, she makes it clear there’s no boundary she wouldn’t cross to ensure his safety. Yet, the series deftly explores the quiet cracks in the notion of endless parental sacrifice—the fatigue after countless tantrums, the guilt of missed bedtimes, and the sobering truth that no parent can shield a child from every harm.

Emotional Core and Themes

The show’s real strength lies in these intimate, imperfect dynamics. As Marissa and her husband Peter (Jake Lacy) endure the agony of their son’s disappearance, the narrative probes profound emotional dilemmas: how love collides with control, and how guilt can twist even the purest intentions.

A Thoughtful Domestic Mystery

Though not as layered as the genre-defining Big Little Lies, All Her Fault remains an engaging and well-crafted mystery. It’s packed with smart twists, sharp observations, and a keen awareness of class tension and the fragility of family life beneath a polished surface.

Review Summary: A gripping domestic thriller that examines the boundaries of parental devotion, powered by Sarah Snook’s heartfelt performance and a suspenseful, emotional narrative.

Author’s Summary: A tense, emotionally resonant thriller exploring the limits of love and control through the haunting story of a mother’s fight to recover her missing child.

The Hollywood Reporter — 2025-11-06